This site is an archived version of Indymedia prior to 5th November 2012. The current site is at

Tuhoe and Crown reach deal to be presented to iwi members


In a media statement, Minister for Treaty of Waitangi Negotiations Christopher Finlayson and Ngāi Tuhoe Chief negotiator Tamati Kruger announced today that the negotiation teams have reached an agreement which will now have to be ratified by the people. It will be interesting to see if this proposal will get support from iwi members.


Hon Christopher Finlayson
Minister for Treaty of Waitangi Negotiations

11 September 2012 Media Statement

Crown Offer Accepted by Ngai Tuhoe Settlement Negotiators
After consultation with iwi members, Te Kotahi a Tuhoe have accepted the Crown’s offer to settle the historical claims of Ngai Tuhoe, Minister for Treaty of Waitangi Negotiations Christopher Finlayson and Ngāi Tuhoe Chief negotiator Tamati Kruger announced today.

“The Crown and Ngai Tuhoe will now work together to develop a Deed of Settlement by the end of 2012,” Mr Finlayson said. “Once completed, the Deed will be initialled by the negotiators. If the deed is then ratified by iwi members, the settlement will be signed and given effect through legislation.”

“This is an historic day confirming the ability of the Crown and Tuhoe to work together into the future, according to the Relationship Agreement signed by us in 2011”, Tamati Kruger said.

I am delighted to reach the goal of a Crown offer that can be developed into a Deed of Settlement,” Mr Finlayson said.
“Ngāi Tuhoe’s history shows clearly why it is so important to settle genuine historical Treaty grievances,” Mr Finlayson said.
“The conditions in Te Urewera, which contains some of our most deprived and isolated communities, show the very real and continued effects of the Crown’s Treaty breaches on the daily lives of Ngāi Tuhoe people in the present.“
“Huge areas of the iwi’s land were wrongly confiscated, and more purchased unjustly. Military campaigns against Tuhoe prisoners and civilians were described even at the time as ‘extermination’, and the Crown employed a scorched earth policy in Tuhoe settlements in the Te Urewera.”
“All elements of the proposed settlement are important but the redress relating to Te Urewera is vital to both parties,” Mr Finlayson said. “For Ngai Tuhoe recognition as tangata whenua in Te Urewera is essential. For both the Crown and Ngāi Tuhoe, the maintenance of the values of a national park is equally important. It became clear to both parties that ownership neither by the Crown nor Ngāi Tuhoe was essential to reach these goals.”

During negotiations, Tuhoe also conducted its own extensive consulting with stakeholders in Te Urewera, such as conservation, hunting and recreation groups. “We discovered that all groups share a real common purpose in protecting Te Urewera’s unique identity,” Mr Kruger said.

Te Urewera will have its own legislation and exist as a separate legal identity. It will be governed by Crown and Ngai Tuhoe nominees acting on its behalf. Ngāi Tuhoe will have an increasing role in management over time, with the Department of Conservation also retaining its role. The Department of Conservation will work with Ngai Tuhoe to enhance Te Urewera as a place of outstanding natural, recreational and cultural value.
Both parties are keen to seek higher international recognition for Te Urewera such as a UNESCO biosphere reserve to promote the areas’ unique values. The legislation will include key provisions from the National Parks Act such as the protection of natural and historic heritage, public input into management and public access into the future.

“This new structure will allow the historical, cultural and spiritual connection between Te Urewera and Ngai Tuhoe to be fully recognised for the first time while the biodiversity of the area is protected and enhanced and public access is guaranteed for all New Zealanders,” Mr Finlayson said.

“The status of Te Urewera is unique and we have together developed an innovative, New Zealand made settlement proposal,” Mr Kruger said.
The offer includes redress valued at approximately $170 million, inclusive of Tuhoe’s share in the Central North Island forestry on-account settlement in 2008.
The offer also includes the implementation of the social Services Management Plan announced last month, under which government agencies will work with Tuhoe to ensure better delivery of social services such as housing, education and health to its communities.
The Crown and Ngāi Tūhoe will discuss the offer with neighbouring iwi, including Ngai Manawa and Ngati Whare who have existing Treaty settlement redress over parts of Te Urewera, and ensure their interests in Te Urewera will also be provided for. This includes redress provided to Ngati Manawa over their ancestral mountain, Tawhiuau.


Annette Sykes writes: "I

Annette Sykes writes: "I think if you look at the deal that the underlying title may not vest with Tuhoe at all.. This is just another comanagment model similar to the Waikato River Deal which is now being relooked at by virtue of the water rights claims"

Something is rotten in the state

Does anyone else find it suspicious that this announcement and the "consultation" which will follow is coming out while the more radical Tūhoe champions are tied up supporting Tame and Rangi in their appeal? I can't see how any settlement between the Crown and Tūhoe can be full and final until all Operation 8 charges are dropped, and a Royal Commission/ Waitangi Tribunal report identifies who is responsible for the NZ Police being used to terrorise whole towns in Tūhoe country, for spurious reasons.

Alternatively you could say

Alternatively you could say Tame's army did damn well for the little practical disruption that they actually caused.  $170million sounds like quite a lot to me (although it's next to nothing compared to the GDP of Pakeha New Zealand).

We know who authorised the raids: Helen Clark.   What we don't know is who talked - who was Tame's "Bob Lambert"? (or "Karl Volkner").  

And what's the point of a Crown inquiry?   Any inquiry would need to be under Tuhoe jurisdiction, tried and punished under Tuhoe law. That's a one way trip to Ruatoki for Clarke, Annette King, Howard Broad & the STG. I'm they'd rather keep their eyeballs, and their heads. 


Tuhoe land is a long way from Texas

There must be oil reserves in Tuhoe land that the Texan oil companies know about.  That's why they pressured Helen Clarke to stamp the boot.

The "agreement" is an Indian treaty.  We all know how the Texans deal with treaties.